Category: Local

Tikva has a lead role to play

Left to right: Linda Thomas (Tikva), Shirley Barnett, Shelley Karrel (Tikva) and Eldad Goldfarb (Jewish Community Centre of Greater Vancouver) at Tikva Housing’s annual general meeting on Dec. 7. (photo from Tikva Housing)

The following remarks have been slightly modified from the original talk given at the Tikva Housing Society annual general meeting on Dec. 7, 2017, which took place at the Jewish Community Centre of Greater Vancouver.

I am sure some of you, if not most of you, are wondering, “Why has Shirley been asked to speak tonight?” I wondered the same thing. So, with some trepidation, I accepted the invitation to say a few words, but will start off with a few disclaimers.

First of all, I really don’t know much about housing. I have never been a part of any task force on housing. I have never attended a conference on housing. Experts in the field are in the media every single day, exploring solutions and dealing with options to solve Vancouver’s escalating housing crisis. Ideas range from adding back the 13th floor of high rises, using that floor for public amenities, to establishing a $100 million fund to speed up development applications. Other ideas have surfaced that call for a complete change in our zoning regulations.

Today, I was at a luncheon and sat next to two women who live at the Performing Arts Lodge (better known as the PAL Housing complex), which is across from the Westin Bayshore. They live under an arrangement I had previously heard about, called a life lease, which sort of bridges renting and ownership. You pay an entry fee for the right of a lifetime lease or for a fixed long-term period. That’s your equity. The society invests the money and you get your money back when you leave.

I have also heard about SAMs, shared appreciation mortgages, where mortgages are granted in exchange for sharing in the profits when the property is sold. This idea has been used to make down payments. The City of Calgary in a partnership with the Province of Alberta established a program whereby forgivable interest-free loans are provided through a housing society they started, and owners remit some of the equity when they leave or sell.

In Vancouver, no matter what the underlying causes are of the “affordability” issue, the very word conjures up the image of ownership as a priority. If we can, let’s discard that vocabulary for a minute and look at some alternative models because the one thing the experts agree on is that there is a need to think differently. Recently, I read there is no “housing crisis” but that there is a “housing supply myth” and we are building beyond our population numbers. In light of this, the City of Vancouver has stated they are now looking at the demand and not the supply.

What is the demand for housing in our own Jewish community?

Time and time again, people have expressed concern about members of our community moving away from the Oak Street corridor. This is already a reality and it will continue. So, instead of talking about people moving out, let’s talk about people moving into new neighbourhoods.

During the 2017 annual campaign, Jewish Federation of Greater Vancouver’s theme was to connect people who live in other municipalities or cities near Vancouver to Jewish programs and services. Their slogan for this was, “We can’t afford to lose them.” I have learned that Federation has hired a community development worker to liaise with emerging Jewish communities and that they are contacting many Jewish people who live in Langley, Maple Ridge, Abbotsford and so on, to ascertain what Jewish components residents in these places want in their lives and in their children’s lives; what initiatives they want to start or enhance or with which they need help.

We know that when an initiative comes from the grassroots, it becomes an emotional experience and, when there is emotion in a group of stakeholders, there is motivation, action and progress. This is how the Burquest Jewish Community Association started, which now has more than 70 families drawn from Burnaby, New Westminster, Coquitlam, Port Moody and further east. The Chabad Centre for Judaism of the Lower Fraser Valley in Surrey started very small and also has grown tremendously. Closer to home, Or Shalom on Fraser Street, which used to be on the outskirts of Vancouver, is now in the city centre and is thriving. East Side Jews, a Temple Sholom initiative, recently had 80 people turn out for an event. And, last summer, 60 kids in outlying areas went for the first time to a Jewish summer day camp run by the Jewish Community Centre of Greater Vancouver. So, we know that Jewish communities can begin and grow outside of Vancouver’s “traditional” neighbourhoods.

If there were an incentive for 10 Jewish families to move somewhere, maybe there could be resources to help them – rental subsidies for house-sharing, help to start a new daycare centre or to open a satellite shul in someone’s basement. Maybe the next development for Tikva Housing should be in one of the smaller communities that is growing a new Jewish population.

But let’s return for a moment to the situation in Vancouver. And let’s explore the availability of the existing housing inventory. Dozens of Jewish families own hundreds of condos in this city. If one unit per building or even one unit per owner were made available for Tikva to manage, this would create an inventory of housing. Tikva manages the inventory; it becomes a clearinghouse for rentals. And Tikva’s rental subsidy program could kick in – it would ensure that these units remain affordable, while providing owners with rental income at market rates. Alternatively, the owners of these rental or condo buildings could donate a unit to Tikva or become major donors to the Esther Dayson Rental Subsidy Program. So many more families could be helped by the above ways – like interest, the success would be compounded so many times.

What about incentives to families willing to create new suites from their unfinished basements and assign those new units to Tikva to manage, again creating new rental stock? I am not sure if you need a permit to finish off your basement but you may need some financial help. Perhaps that is an area of lending for the Hebrew Free Loan Association.

With the major redevelopment of Oakridge Centre and across the street from the Vancouver JCC at the former transit centre and all along 41st Avenue, as well as the need to redevelop both the current JCC and the Louis Brier Home and Hospital, we are in for an exciting time. The entire area will be repurposed and densified, whether we like it or not, and we need to do our part in a new, different way.

This should be the time when Tikva works together with Yaffa Housing, with the Vancouver Jewish Building Society that, together with the Netherlands Association, has 133 units, and with the Shalom Branch of the Canadian Legion that has 102 units. It boggles the mind (or, at least, my mind) that, for a community as small as ours, there are four Jewish housing societies that, for the most part, do not work together. Imagine the benefits that could be accomplished if these agencies were merged or formed loose partnerships or even a central registry. Why should someone in need in our community have to deal with sorting out the various agencies and options? But that’s a topic for another meeting.

There are more and more newspaper articles about redoing the concept of single-family zoning areas. There is much discussion about how large homes can be repurposed. How many people really want or need a home in Shaughnessy, on Marine Drive or in Richmond with eight or nine bedrooms and the same number of bathrooms? Should the city allow the change of dozens of these homes into four or six units for purchase or rental? Of course. What about financial incentives for young Jewish families, empty nesters or seniors who would like to share a large home but can’t afford the renovations to do so?

There is a philosophy about “aging in place,” staying in your own home until such time as your health requires you to leave. What about when your finances require you to leave because you can’t afford to pay your taxes or for the home’s upkeep? A recent article in the Vancouver Sun stated that one-third of the senior population, mostly women, live alone, and many suffer from depression, financial need and social isolation. We need to rethink what it means to live at home. Many people have said they don’t want to live in complexes built only for people their own age. This is a huge factor in senior living.

The same Sun article quotes a study published by the Gerontologist Society of America, which argues we have to broaden our meaning of “place” from an individual home to mean a neighbourhood. It continues, “Home is a refuge, but it is as much the background of the home, the familiarity with the places and contacts around it that provide security, as any emotional attachment to the home itself.”

We know people can feel as isolated and as disconnected living in a condo as they would living alone in a house. Not only do we need amenities in buildings but inviting spaces, not just gyms but places where the coffee and the lights are always on, lobbies where people can meet and chat – a community within a building within a neighbourhood.

Let me illustrate this point with a great example of building a new neighbourhood without cost. Those of us who live in condos know that the key fobs to enter our units usually cannot be used on other floors; you can’t visit someone on another floor without going down to the lobby and buzzing back up. We know that the intention is greater security and preventing unwanted visitors, but Tikva used an innovative approach. When the 18 units of the Diamond Residences in Richmond were being built, the fobs to the units on the Tikva floors – floors 12, 13 and 14 – were calibrated to give access to all the Tikva floors. You don’t have to go outside the building and buzz someone to get back in to visit them or borrow a cup of sugar. Families can visit other residents on the other Tikva floors. Children can go back and forth from their own apartments to their friends or relatives. That’s building a new neighbourhood.

As I mentioned before, I have no experience in solving these types of issues but I do know that the solutions will take much more creativity than we have ever seen, creativity at many different levels, including from within our Jewish community. One of my favourite quotations is from Albert Einstein, who said, “No problem can be solved by the same level of consciousness that created it.”

I believe Tikva not only has a role in community development but also an expanded role. Our family feels good about this. We think we have chosen wisely to support the initiatives of Tikva because of their potential in being a leader in this area: affordable housing using many different models, but together with community development. My brother Philip Dayson and I are privileged to be able to participate in Tikva’s new project on Marine Drive – imagine 32 family homes in a new Jewish community in a land trust implemented by a group of nonprofit organizations together with the City of Vancouver. And we are very proud to say this complex will be named after our parents.

I cannot close without remembering the brilliance of Susana Cogan, z”l, and, thinking of her, we will recommit our support to Tikva Housing with the expectation that this organization will lead us down new pathways and, like Susana, show imagination, strength and leadership outside of anyone’s box.

***

More about Tikva Housing’s AGM

Tikva Housing had its annual general meeting on Dec. 7, 2017, at the Jewish Community Centre of Greater Vancouver, with approximately 50 people in attendance. The society provided an overview of its current housing capacity, the ongoing need for affordable housing and the challenges facing the Metro Vancouver Jewish community with regards to housing.

Tikva has 18 units in the Diamond Residences, in Richmond, which opened in September 2017; 11 units at the Danny Guincher Residences; and 32 units will be available at the Esther and Ben Dayson Residences, in Vancouver, opening in summer 2018. The society has the Esther Dayson Rent Subsidy Program, which supports approximately 40 recipients.

Tikva’s main partners are the Jewish Federation of Greater Vancouver, which maintained annual funding for Tikva’s operations for 2017/18; Jewish Family Services, which refers people who are in need of affordable housing; and Kehila Society, which links tenants living in the Diamond Residences with events and services in Richmond.

The units at Diamond Residences range from studios to three-bedrooms. Because of the Diamond Foundation, as well as the Irving and Phyliss Snider, Lohn and Zalkow foundations, which contributed to the capital costs, it is posible to offer rents set at 30% of household income.

The Esther and Ben Dayson Residences is a partnership of Tikva Housing with the Community Land Trust Foundation and City of Vancouver. Its townhouses, ranging from two- to four-bedrooms, will offer 16 units for families on income assistance and 16 units renting at 30% of household income. The Ben and Esther Dayson Charitable Foundation have committed to fund Tikva’s equity loan to the Vancouver Land Trust project.

– Courtesy of Tikva Housing Society

 

At controversy’s centre – Louis Brier

Louis Brier Home and Hospital has accused Dr. Ellen Wiebe, who specializes in medically assisted dying, of wrongdoing, for providing a medically assisted death to 83-year-old resident Barry Hyman, without the consent or knowledge of the care facility.

The home accused Wiebe of “borderline unethical” behaviour and has filed a complaint with the College of Physicians and Surgeons, but Wiebe is adamant that her actions were not unprofessional.

“By far the most important thing is the patient,” Wiebe told the CJN. “The second is the family. Mr. Hyman’s wish was to die in his home. People have all kinds of wishes and desires, but dying wishes are held to a higher standard than other wishes.”

Asked about the family’s agreement to abide by Louis Brier’s policies, and the dispensation given by the B.C. Ministry of Health for institutions to refuse the provision of services that go against their religious beliefs, Wiebe said, “I’m not part of those agreements. My agreement is purely with my patient, not the facility, and since I don’t have visiting privileges at Louis Brier like I do at Vancouver General Hospital, I am not required to abide by the agreement between Louis Brier and the ministry.”

Wiebe was invited into the facility by Hyman’s daughter, Lola Hyman, and his other immediate family members, who wanted to honour Barry Hyman’s long-held wish to die on his own terms. Disabled by a stroke and diagnosed with lung cancer, Hyman had asked to die at the care facility, which had become his primary residence. Lola Hyman had broached the topic with David Keselman, the chief executive officer of Louis Brier, who told her it was against their policy, which is formulated according to Orthodox Jewish law.

Lola Hyman told the Globe and Mail that she wanted to honour her father’s wishes in a place that was comfortable for him, not somewhere that would be unfamiliar to him.

On the night of his death, she said, “the room was very quiet. We just held his hand and stared at him. My sister was sobbing, just sobbing. I was a stone. A complete stone. My heart was racing that someone would open the door.”

The Supreme Court of Canada struck down the Criminal Code prohibition on physician-assisted dying in 2015 and the federal government passed legislation legalizing it in 2016. The court recognized that doctors should not be coerced into performing the procedure against their will, but did not specify whether health-care organizations could refuse to comply.

In British Columbia, the Ministry of Health made an agreement that allows members of the Denominational Health Association (DHA), which includes the Louis Brier, to refuse to provide services that are inconsistent with their religious values.

“Anyone who comes here knows what our policy is and, if they don’t like the policy, they should go somewhere else,” Mark Rozenberg, the chair of the ethics committee of Louis Brier’s board, told the Globe and Mail.

Keselman declined the CJN’s request for comment, saying that the board was in meetings to decide how to respond to the media exposure. The home’s rabbi, Hillel Brody, said he was not permitted to discuss Louis Brier’s policies with the press.

Shanaaz Gokool, chief executive officer of Dying With Dignity Canada, told the CJN that organizations like Louis Brier are not being asked to take part in medically assisted dying, but simply not to obstruct residents from a medical service to which they have a right.

“The doctors bring in their own equipment. The health-care facility has no involvement in the procedure. By not allowing this, they are undermining the rights of the residents of Louis Brier who call it their home,” Gokool said.

It is not clear if institutions that refuse to allow medically assisted deaths on their premises enjoy the same Charter-protected religious freedoms as individuals who refuse to provide the service, because the issue has not yet been tested in court.

A joint statement issued by Dying With Dignity Canada and the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers said, “We support health-care professionals who, as a matter of conscience and compassion, help their patients overcome unfair barriers to access.… And we will defend clinicians who are attacked or punished for their participation in the lawful provision of MAID (medical assistance in dying). These courageous individuals should be applauded, not penalized, for putting their patients first.”

Louis Brier is one of a number of faith-based organizations that are in a quandary: although the centre is run in accordance with Orthodox Jewish law, not all residents are religious Jews, and it also has non-Jewish residents.

A 2014 Ipsos-Reid poll conducted on behalf of Dying With Dignity Canada showed that 84% of Canadians were in favour of allowing physicians to help someone die, if that person is suffering and wishes to die.

There is also the issue of public funding, as “67% of the Louis Brier’s funding is public,” said Gokool. “They are funded by taxpayers and should abide by Canadian law.”

Lola Hyman told the Globe that she was left feeling distressed, both at the possibility of Wiebe suffering on account of helping her father, and at having upset the front-line staff at Louis Brier, who were shocked by Barry Hyman’s sudden death. She said that all of this could have been avoided if British Columbia went the way of Quebec and stopped allowing publicly funded organizations to obstruct the rights of their residents.

“Everyone is entitled to their religious beliefs and traditions and customs,” Hyman told the Globe. “But, when it comes to somebody who is very sick and dying, we need to have a different approach.”

Matthew Gindin is a freelance journalist, writer and lecturer. He writes regularly for the Forward and All That Is Interesting, and has been published in Religion Dispatches, Situate Magazine, Tikkun and elsewhere. He can be found on Medium and Twitter. This article was originally published by the CJN, cjnews.com.

Praise for whistleblowers

Alan Le Fevre, president of the Wallenberg-Sugihara Civil Courage Society, and Acting Mayor Raymond Louie, right, with the City of Vancouver’s proclamation of Raoul Wallenberg Day. (photo by Masumi Kikuchi)

“If we had a society that was free from embezzlement, free of theft, free of dishonesty, free of unethical conduct, we wouldn’t need whistleblowers. But, unfortunately, we are not a perfect society,” said Ujjal Dosanjh in his keynote address at the 13th annual Raoul Wallenberg Day event, which was held on Jan. 14 at the H.R. MacMillan Space Centre.

Dosanjh, a former federal cabinet minister, B.C. attorney general and the province’s 33rd premier, was, in 2015, the inaugural recipient of the Wallenberg-Sugihara Civil Courage Society’s Civil Courage Award. He was recognized for “his great courage in the face of escalating violence by extremists in the Indo-Canadian community that arose from conflicts that had erupted in India,” said WSCCS board member Ana Policzer in her remarks on Sunday.

The society hosts the annual Wallenberg Day event and, this year, they honoured Vancouver-based lawyer Alayne Fleischmann with the Civil Courage Award.

Fleischmann was born in Terrace, B.C. She got her bachelor’s degree in philosophy from the University of British Columbia, her master’s in international and comparative law from the Institute of International and Comparative Law, Cornell Law School and Université Paris (Sorbonne), and her juris doctor degree from Cornell. In 2006, she was working in quality control at JPMorgan Chase in New York. There, she discovered and tried to stop what she described as “massive criminal securities fraud” – mortgage operations similar to those of many other financial institutions, which led to the 2008 economic collapse. Her efforts resulted in a $9 billion fine being levied on JPMorgan Chase, but no one from the bank was ever prosecuted. She moved back to British Columbia in 2008.

In a 2014 Rolling Stone article, writer Matt Taibbi goes into great detail about Fleischmann’s experiences, the difficulties she faced in bringing the truth to light and the limited impact the truth played in whatever minor justice was carried out against all the banks guilty of mortgage-related wrongdoings. In effect, Taibbi argues, the U.S. department of justice “struck a series of historic settlement deals with Chase, Citigroup and Bank of America. The root bargain in these deals was cash for secrecy. The banks paid big fines, without trials or even judges – only secret negotiations that typically ended with the public shown nothing but vague, quasi-official papers called ‘statements of facts,’ which were conveniently devoid of anything like actual facts.”

The full Rolling Stone article can be accessed via wsccs.ca/wallenberg-days/2018. At the Wallenberg Day event, organizers screened a 2014 interview with Taibbi and Fleischmann by Democracy Now! WSCCS president Alan Le Fevre also spoke briefly about Fleischmann’s actions and why she was chosen to receive the Civil Courage Award. Unfortunately, Fleischmann could not accept the award in person because of the ongoing litigation.

In his remarks, Dosanjh saluted whistleblowers. “In Canada,” he said, “we don’t know too many of our own heroes…. But we have them. One that we have amongst us in Canada is the honouree tonight, Alayne Fleischmann.”

There are monetary costs to illegitimate or immoral actions, Dosanjh said, but such actions also “jeopardize the health, safety and well-being of the employees, the customers and the society of the institutions.”

Whistleblowers like Fleischmann set out to right a wrong, he said. They are morally compelled to the point where they take the “risk of losing their careers,” “being ostracized” and having rumours spread about them to “delegitimize the truth that they’re trying to tell.”

After such individuals come forward, he said, “life is never the same. You lose friends, you lose relationships, obviously you lose a job possibly, or you’re not promoted or you’re demoted…. And, sometimes, it can be dangerous physically. People have been known to be killed, at least across the border, for trying to expose the truth. Karen Silkwood comes to mind.”

Dosanjh warned that whistleblowers aren’t always correct, however, giving the example of eight B.C. health ministry workers who were found to have been wrongly dismissed in 2012, amid allegations of wrongdoing. “It’s a risky business,” he said. “You’re playing with your own life but you’re also playing with the lives of others you’re trying to expose.” So, you have to not only have the courage to speak up, he said, but the wisdom to know when to not do so, or when to investigate further before doing so.

Several audience members gave their take on corporate and government corruption in the question-and-answer period. Dosanjh said people need to get more vocal about these issues. “There is no silver bullet to deal with any particular issue,” he said. “It’s just a matter of becoming more active politically and raising your voices.”

To an audience member who decried greed as criminal, Dosanjh said, “If you say greed is the basic urge to make more money, that shouldn’t be a crime…. You want to make money, you want to work more … that’s what keeps the world going…. Illegal greed should be a crime – and it already is! The fact is we’re not prosecuting criminals, we’re not apprehending them, we’re not investigating them as much as we should, and we’re falling down in some respects.”

The afternoon event also included the reading by Acting Mayor Raymond Louie of the City of Vancouver proclamation of Jan. 14 as Raoul Wallenberg Day. He thanked event organizers and attendees for taking the time “to remember and to also recommit … with this ongoing effort to have a better world overall.”

The WSCCS is continually “seeking to identify people who, at significant personal risk, have helped to improve or save the lives of others by going against unjust laws or conventions.” For more information, visit wsccs.ca.

NCJW pays tribute to Poliakoff

Left to right: former National Council of Jewish Women Vancouver section president Shirley Hyman; Gloria Hendin, tribute committee chair; Barbara Heller, longtime supporter of council; Marion Poliakoff, the guest of honour; Bonnie Gertsman, former Vancouver section president; Anne Melul, former Vancouver section membership chair; and Debby Altow, past president, Vancouver section. (photo by Joanne Emerman)

National Council of Jewish Women hosted a tea at Temple Sholom on Jan. 9 to celebrate Marion Poliakoff, a true Renaissance woman. At 94 years young, she continues to be an inspiration to council members past and present.

Poliakoff’s career and her personal life demonstrate the principles of NCJW: fostering multiculturalism, alleviating poverty among women and children, supporting family counseling in Israel through ALUMA, and cherishing music and family. Her commitment to clear and convincing communication has been a boon to many newsletter writers – and she continues to edit us closely.

Gloria Hendin, who chaired the event committee, welcomed everyone. Shelagh Stoller bought the gift for Poliakoff, which Shirley Hyman presented. Barbara Heller managed all the banner decorations, Bonnie Gertsman and Anne Melul organized the food, and Judy Stern greeted guests as they arrived. The entertainment came courtesy of Poliakoff’s daughter, Amy Poliakoff, who brought her flute from Boston. I delivered the tribute speech, which I share below.

Vancouver section president Catherine Stoller set the tone for the annual general meeting that followed the celebration. “Looking backward, we recall our ancestry. Looking forward, we confront our destiny,” she said. The board of directors was installed by Shanie Levin with those words ringing in their ears!

In preparing my remarks, I read Melul’s biographical notes on Poliakoff, Carol Weinstock’s article on NCJW in the Jewish Museum and Archives of British Columbia’s journal, The Scribe, and the book More Than Just Mrs.: Jewish Women’s Organizations in B.C., as well as the council’s cookbook. Of course, I also spoke with many council members who worked with Poliakoff, and reflected on my own personal experiences with her. With some minor editing, to reflect their publication after the event, my remarks follow.

Marion was born in the United States. Holding a bachelor’s from Simmons College in Massachusetts and a master’s in journalism from New York’s Columbia University, she married Mel Poliakoff in 1949, adopting Mel’s son Merrill at the same time. Although at first they were unable to live in Tenafly, N.J., because, as Jews, they could not buy a house there, nevertheless they did move there a few years later. She became the first Jew elected to public office, serving on the board of education.

In 1972, she moved to West Vancouver with her husband and their daughters Amy and Nan. They loved tennis, skiing and sailing. Sadly, Merrill and Nan are gone, but many of Marion’s family were able to join the council’s tribute.

When Marion met Bess Narod – Bess is from Ottawa; I knew her family back home – they went to an NCJW meeting, and that was the start of Marion’s connection with council. The first big item she worked on, the hearing screening project in schools, demonstrated council’s mission: identify a need, pilot a response, make it a success and turn it over to government. The Vancouver health department now runs it.

Marion also met Rita Weintraub, who became a lifelong friend. Together, they have worked to support the Isaac Waldman Jewish Public Library at the Jewish Community Centre of Greater Vancouver.

Meanwhile, Marion got another master’s degree – from the University of British Columbia’s School of Social Work – and, through a field placement at Britannia Community Centre, became interested in multicultural issues. Always the consummate writer, she contributed the Multicultural Corner column to the monthly newsletter of the B.C. Association of Social Workers; another column went into the Britannia newsletter, which was translated into Italian and Chinese.

The City of Vancouver grabbed Marion and she ran parenting groups for mothers in three community centres – using translators for Farsi, Chinese and Italian participants. In 1981, she received the Social Worker of the Year Award from the B.C. Association of Social Workers for her multicultural work.

I met her when I was the director of communications for the Canadian Cancer Society and she was a social worker at the B.C. Cancer Agency. I was working on breast cancer issues, with multicultural projects for Chinese and South Asian women. We found we had much in common.

Marion was also the one who called me every year to pay my NCJW dues, even though I was not an active volunteer in those years. She recruited me after I retired to join the board and, 13 years later, I’m still on it in one capacity or another.

In 1991, HIPPY (Home Instruction for Parents of Preschool Youngsters) was brought to Canada from Israel as a council initiative by Carol Slater. Ever alert to new connections, Marion linked Britannia, along with Simon Fraser University, to council as our community partners to launch the HIPPY project. She was intimately involved in establishing its work with immigrant mothers and their families. While its name has changed to the Mothers Matter Centre, HIPPY remains one of council’s programs, and Wazi Kapenda, its Western director, was in attendance at the tribute.

Marion’s volunteering extended to driving people to services at Congregation Har El, eventually donating her beloved baby grand piano to the shul, fundraising for the synagogue, and cooking and serving food weekly to needy and homeless people at Harvest House.

Later, she joined the North Shore Osteoporosis Society, organizing monthly speakers. I spoke at one gathering and there were more than 100 people attending – a not uncommon number!

Her commitment to ALUMA (formerly the Israel Family Counseling Agency) was, and continues to be, an inspiration. She fought for support for ALUMA in council, because the organization was dedicated to supporting people in Israel who could not afford professional counseling but who desperately needed it. And Judy Stern could always count on Marion to canvass for Friends and Angels, council’s only annual fundraiser.

Marion’s was a home where music was loved and valued, even after the piano was gone. She supported the Vancouver Symphony, the Vancouver Chamber Music Society and Music in the Morning. Music continues to be a tree of life for many of her family members. Her close friend Shirley Lecker is part of that tradition.

Do you see a thread unspooling here – with HIPPY, with anti-poverty issues, with a commitment to Jewish values, with a passion for family, with a professional eye for communication, with an abiding love of music? When I said Renaissance woman, the label is legitimate.

It is such an honour to acknowledge Marion for her work with council – and with many of us personally. It is beyond words. To simply say thank you is really inadequate. But, from the bottom of my heart, and from all of us, thank you, Marion.

Hatikvah bursting at seams

Land-based activities at Camp Hatikvah form a large part of the summer experience. (photo from camphatikvah.com)

Like most everything, camp enrolment goes in cycles. And, for the past few years, Camp Hatikvah has had a waiting list for its first session, a full second session and has closed off the summers with the highly popular Family Camp experience that sells out within hours of registration opening in October the year prior. With the largest-ever single age group of campers rising through the ranks, Hatikvah is looking to expand its facilities to accommodate these campers as they move toward the counselor-in-training program.

Camp Hatikvah has a formula that seems to be working well. In order to fill every bunk, current board president Joanna Wasel worked closely with camp director Liza Rozen-Delman to make some changes in programming. In addition, they have brought the concept of camper care front and centre, and the programming is more flexible than the camp experience of yesteryear. As but one example, Hatikvah has been bringing in specialist instructors for activities such as tennis or mountain biking to run weekly sessions, and such initiatives are drawing campers. Once their interest is piqued, the kids tend to come back year after year.

“Liza does an excellent job ensuring that the campers are well cared for, safe and happy,” said Wasel. “I believe her reputation of providing exceptional camper care is the primary reason we are seeing the success we are today.”

photo - Camp Hatikvah, 1972. Sailing was one of the writer’s favourite camp activities
Camp Hatikvah, 1972. Sailing was one of the writer’s favourite camp activities. (photo from Jewish Western Bulletin fonds, Jewish Museum and Archives of BC L.09596)

While Camp Hatikvah has been known for years as a watersport camp, the land-based activities have been overhauled during Wasel’s tenure as president. “We are now able to offer expert instruction from professionals in a plethora of land activities including tennis, football, basketball, fitness, yoga, dance and more,” she told the Independent. “The change has been dramatic and campers are now equally engaged on land and water.”

Those who remember their own experiences of the “good old days” of camp continue the tradition, and send their children, according to Rozen-Delman. “Many of our campers are second- or third-generation participants,” she said. “Our camp is rich in traditions and many of the programs we offer our campers today are based on programs their grandparents participated in during the ’50s and ’60s and their parents did in the ’70s and ’80s. We are very proud of this dedication to our roots and traditions and believe this makes our camp experience even more meaningful.”

The list of former campers reads a bit like a who’s who of the local Jewish community, something that shows the link between camp attendance and Jewish community involvement. Many of the children from Camp Hatikvah are already well ensconced within the community; many are students at Vancouver Talmud Torah. Rozen-Delman noted that campers also come from Alberta, Ontario, Washington and California. Hatikvah has combined a number of initiatives to draw a diverse group of campers, some of whom have no other connection with the Jewish community.

The effort to diversify and attract unaffiliated Jews this year has been aided by the Laskin Outreach Fund. This initiative, created and entirely funded by Elliot and Megan Laskin, provides $1,800 (almost the full fee) to first-time campers from British Columbia with little or no Jewish communal engagement to try Camp Hatikvah in its second summer session.

Both Wasel and Rozen-Delman stress that the programming at Camp Hatikvah is oriented toward helping children develop as members of the community. As a pluralistic camp, children from all sorts of Jewish backgrounds are introduced to and experience the camp’s motto: “Leadership by example.”

Although the programming for younger campers is focused on fun and socializing, with some Zionist and Jewish learning, it is the staff-in-training (SIT) program that begins the leadership training in earnest.

“This program is designed specifically to enhance the leadership abilities and traits of our campers. Participants engage in almost daily hadracha (leadership) sessions or discussions where they learn the importance of leadership, citizenship and community,” said Rozen-Delman of SIT.

Both Wasel and Rozen-Delman are alumna of Camp Hatikvah, with Wasel starting as a camper in 1988 and Rozen-Delman in 1979. Both have worked and volunteered within the Jewish community, in addition to their work at Camp Hatikvah.

While local Jewish life is part of the formula, Hatikvah’s Zionist roots are as strong as ever. Last summer, there were 14 Israeli schlichim (emissaries) on staff.

This year’s camp sessions are both looking like they will be full, said Rozen-Delman. For more information on the camp, subsidies to attend or the Laskin Outreach initiative, call the camp office at 604-263-1200.

Michelle Dodek is a freelance writer who spent one summer at Camp Hatikvah a long time ago and loved the sailing program.

Be an angel in February

Rose’s Angels provides hygiene care packages, nonperishable food items and warmth bundles to 1,000 Richmond individuals in need. (photo by Lianne Cohen Photography)

The month of February is special because it’s both Heart Month and the birthday month of Rose Lewin, after whom Rose’s Angels is named.

“The Kehila Society’s Rose’s Angels program is celebrating its fifth year this coming February,” said organizer and co-founder Courtney Cohen. “As the need for care packages has increased every year since our inception, and after receiving feedback and input from service agency’s and their recipients, we’ve been able to extend our outreach efforts this year. This program continues to honour Rose Lewin and Babs Cohen in the truest form of tzedakah and love for our Richmond community.”

Rose’s Angels provides hygiene care packages, nonperishable food items and warmth bundles to 1,000 Richmond individuals in programs such as Richmond Family Place, Salvation Army, Jewish Food Bank, Richmond Food Bank, Kehila Meals on Wheels and other similar Richmond outreach initiatives.

For the care packages, Rose’s Angels are looking for the following items: packaged dried fruit or nuts (raisins, trail mix, etc.); canned foods, such as soup and tuna; boxed foods, like macaroni and cheese, rice and pasta; individually packaged baked goods (granola bars, energy bars, cookies, oatmeal, pudding, Jell-O, etc.) that are still sealed; peanut butter; juice boxes, hot chocolate and tea; individually wrapped chocolates; toiletry items such as toothbrushes, toothpaste, deodorant, floss, soap, mini shampoo/conditioner and tissues; feminine hygiene products; beauty care products (hair accessories, lotion, makeup); gloves or mittens, both children- and adult-size; toques; and thermal socks.

If you would like to come out on Feb. 11 to assist in packaging the bundles or would like to donate items and/or funds or help with package deliveries, call the Kehila Society office at 604-241-9270 or email [email protected].

An education legacy

In October, our community lost one of its most devoted supporters, Leon Glassman, z”l. Leon will be remembered for generations to come for his commitment to Jewish education and its central role in Jewish identity and continuity. Through the Jewish Community Foundation, Leon created a legacy that reflects his lifelong passion in these areas. Together with his wife Rose Marie, they made an indelible impact on our community – an impact that will ensure his memory lives on.

Leon and Rose Marie’s commitment to Jewish education goes back decades to their life as young parents in Regina. Their move to Vancouver was motivated in part because here they would be able to provide their children with a Jewish education, which they saw as an integral aspect of helping them develop strong Jewish identities.

Leon and Rose Marie recognized that the high cost of living in the Lower Mainland today has reduced the ability of many families to enrol their children in Jewish day schools and Jewish educational programs. They wanted to find a way not just to help families and children, but to strengthen Jewish continuity for the community as a whole.

In April 2016, Leon and Rose Marie made a million-dollar gift to create the Leon Glassman Fund for Jewish Continuity through Education endowment fund. The response from community members who share their passion, as well as from the day school community that understands so clearly the impact this endowment will make, was tremendous, and it inspired Leon and Rose Marie to make a second million-dollar gift to the fund.

The fund will provide a steady source of support for tuition assistance, so more children can reap the benefits of a Jewish day school education. This endowment will support an area of need that was close to Leon’s heart, enriching our community in perpetuity.

According to executive director Marcie Flom, the Jewish Community Foundation was “privileged to work with the Glassmans to create Leon’s legacy for the Jewish community.” She said, “Leon’s philanthropy reflected his life’s passion and his commitment to Jewish education in a way that perpetuates his memory for his children and grandchildren.”

Like Leon and Rose Marie, there are many community members who support causes that reflect their interests and their values. If you are among them, then you, too, can create a legacy at the Jewish Community Foundation that reflects your passions. To make a contribution to the Glassman Fund or for more information on how to create a legacy, visit jewishcommunityfoundation.com.

Completing the Tanya

Rabbi Binyomin Bitton (photo by Noam Dehan)

On Dec. 4, Chabad of Downtown Vancouver, led by Rabbi Binyomin Bitton, held a siyyum, a celebration to mark the conclusion of studying the entire book of Tanya, sometimes called “the Bible of Chassidic thought.”

The siyyum also celebrated Yud-Tes Kislev, the 19th day of the Jewish month of Kislev, which began this year on the evening of Dec. 6, and is known as “the New Year of Chassidism,” due to the release of the founder of Chabad and author of the Tanya, Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi, known as the Alter Rebbe, from prison in czarist Russia on that date in 1798.

The Tanya is a guide to the pursuit of righteousness and the meaning of Jewish religious life from a Chabad Chassidic perspective. It is known for its counsel on how the intellect can transform the emotional life, and its teachings on how contemplating the nature of God and the soul can inspire and focus spiritual life. The Tanya also asserts that the height of the spiritual life lies paradoxically in the simple actions of human beings, and that the highest expression of God’s intention in creation is in the human doing of a mitzvah (religious commandment, good deed).

Bitton opened the siyyum by noting his pleasure that it happened to fall so close to Yud-Tes Kislev, when Jews all around the world start a new cycle of Tanya learning. He then welcomed Adina Ragetli, a descendant of the Alter Rebbe, to play the niggun (sacred wordless melody) of the Alter Rebbe, “Arba Bavos,” on the harp.

“We are all very happy tonight,” said Bitton afterwards, “except one person, whose name I won’t say, but I’ll tell you the letters of his name, Samech-Mem-Alef-Lamed [Samael, an evil angel, whose name is not spoken by Chassidim]. You know what the letters of his name stand for? Siyyum masechet lo aseh [the completion of a book you will not do].”

Rivka Arieli read the final section of Tanya with which they completed the book, and then the rabbi invited a series of students to speak of the meaning of the text to them. First to talk were Eduardo and Gabrielle Sonnino, who spoke of their discovery of the meaning of Judaism through the Tanya after coming to Canada from Brazil three years ago. They spoke humorously of their adoption of Jewish observance as a result, teasing Bitton that, in getting them to “leave their cheeseburgers,” he had ruined their lives.

Shirley Hirsch and her husband, Gabriel, had learned previously with Rabbi Lipa Dubrawsky, z”l, the educational director of Chabad-Lubavitch BC for 15 years until his passing in 2013. His wife, Dena Dubrawsky, urged the Hirsches to contact Bitton, and soon they were taking on Tanya every Monday. Hirsch spoke of the uniqueness of the Tanya in conveying the highest mystical truths of Judaism in a form that anyone can understand.

Robert Elias shared how the study of Tanya and its differentiation between the egoic and divine elements in the person had helped him improve his marriage, mend broken friendships, improve his relations with his co-workers, and remove the sense of ennui he was experiencing in his otherwise successful professional life.

Ragetli closed the celebration with another piece of music. Rabbi Yechiel Baitelman of Richmond Chabad also attended the siyyum.

Matthew Gindin is a freelance journalist, writer and lecturer. He writes regularly for the Forward and All That Is Interesting, and has been published in Religion Dispatches, Situate Magazine, Tikkun and elsewhere. He can be found on Medium and Twitter.

Celebrating chai, community

Cynthia Ramsay, publisher of the Jewish Independent. (photo by Alan Katowitz)

The JI Chai Celebration on Dec. 6 at the Rothstein Theatre was a sold-out event. The high-achievers and community-minded individuals who won the JI’s 18 Under 36 Awards were the highlights of an evening that included world-class entertainment and the launch of a brief video explaining the history of the Jewish Independent, which began its newspaper life as the Jewish Western Bulletin.

In my remarks at the celebration, I noted, “For 88 years, this newspaper has been bringing this community together. And yet, in all that time, there has never been an event – to my knowledge – where people have come together – literally, in the same room, like we all are tonight – to celebrate or acknowledge the existence of our community newspaper.

photo - JI’s 18 Under 36er Rabbi Levi Varnai, left, with JI Chai Celebration presenting sponsors Lorne Segal, centre, and Gary Segal
JI’s 18 Under 36er Rabbi Levi Varnai, left, with JI Chai Celebration presenting sponsors Lorne Segal, centre, and Gary Segal. (photo by Alan Katowitz)

“It’s funny to think how many annual general meetings, how many lectures, how many Negev Dinners, Innovators Lunches, JCC Sports Dinners, book festivals, film festivals, social, intellectual, religious events of every description, that the paper has covered in these decades. Yet the community has never before gathered together to turn our gaze toward the newspaper. In 88 years, there has never been an event like tonight’s.”

The JI Chai Celebration was presented by the Jewish Independent with the generous sponsorship of the Joseph and Rosalie Segal family and the Chutzpah! Festival. Both Gary Segal and Lorne Segal presented awards, as did Jewish Federation of Greater Vancouver board chair Karen James and CJPAC B.C. Region director Kara Mintzberg, who was the external adjudicator of the awards. The winners, in alphabetical order, were Rebecca Baron, Ezequiel Blumenkrans, Erin Brandt, Marcus Brandt, Ayelet Cohen Weil, Courtney Cohen, Aaron Friedland, Sam Heller, Talya Mallek, Ariel Martz-Oberlander, Logan Presch, Maya Rae Schwartz-Dardick, Mike Sachs, Allie Saks, David Schein, Rotem Tal, Carmel Tanaka and Rabbi Levi Varnai.

Several community members stepped up as sponsors – Gary Averbach, Shirley Barnett, David Bogoch, Tzipi Mann, JB Newall Memorials, Olive+Wild, Mark James and Red Truck Beer, Vancouver Learning Centre, Byron Sheardown and Web exPress and Yosef Wosk. And all of the performers – Amanda Hartley, Lisa Ehrlich, Goldie Hoffman, Vitaly Beckman, Jacob Samuel, Roller Dance Owl, Barbara Adler, Ron Samworth, Warren Kimmel and Wendy Bross Stuart – donated their time, and the Jewish Museum and Archives of British Columbia created a photo exhibit especially for the occasion. There were dozens of auction and prize donors. Under the direction of Bonnie Nish, JI staff and volunteers helped make the night the success it was.

photo - Left to right, JI’s 18 Under 36 Award winners Rebecca Baron, Ezequiel Blumenkrans, Erin Brandt, Marcus Brandt, Ayelet Cohen Weil, Courtney Cohen, Aaron Friedland, Sam Heller and Talya Mallek
Left to right, JI’s 18 Under 36 Award winners Rebecca Baron, Ezequiel Blumenkrans, Erin Brandt, Marcus Brandt, Ayelet Cohen Weil, Courtney Cohen, Aaron Friedland, Sam Heller and Talya Mallek. (photo by Alan Katowitz)

“I hope we agree on the importance of having a Jewish community newspaper,” I said at the event. “I hope, further, that most of us would like one that represents all segments of the community and most opinions – we do have our red lines, I will admit.

“If we agree, I’m asking you to keep supporting the paper. And, I’m asking those of you who are new to the paper through this event, to subscribe, to advertise your business or organization, or to donate every so often if you prefer to just check out the website or pick the paper up for free at one of our 40 depots.

“And, I’m asking all of you to pass this message on to your friends. This newspaper is our collective record, our community’s mirror and its voice.”

photo - Left to right, JI’s 18 Under 36 Award winners Ariel Martz-Oberlander, Logan Presch, Allie Saks, David Schein, Maya Rae Schwartz-Dardick, Rotem Tal, Carmel Tanaka, Mike Sachs and Rabbi Levi Varnai
Left to right, JI’s 18 Under 36 Award winners Ariel Martz-Oberlander, Logan Presch, Allie Saks, David Schein, Maya Rae Schwartz-Dardick, Rotem Tal, Carmel Tanaka, Mike Sachs and Rabbi Levi Varnai. (photo by Alan Katowitz)

I acknowledged, “Of course, our community has many needs. We have so many superb organizations doing crucial work. And the Jewish Independent can’t give tax receipts like most of the others can. But we’re not a charity – we are your community asset … And we need your support.”

I concluded, “Thank you to everyone who has supported this paper for the past 18 years. In fact, there are some who have supported the paper for most of its 88 years. May I ask you to support us to 120 – and then may it be your grandchildren’s problem.”

To watch the video The Jewish Independent: 88 Years … and Counting!, click here.

School bars Chanukah

The chair of Vancouver Board of Education (VBE) and even the provincial minister of education waded in after Jewish students at a Vancouver elementary school went public with concerns that they were being made to feel excluded by exclusively Christian holiday symbolism.

Students Maya Sontz and Rebecca Weinberg went public last week after asking the principal of General Gordon Elementary, Hope Sterling, to add some Chanukah decorations to the Christmas trees, wreaths and other Christmas decorations up around the school. The girls said they were rebuffed by the principal, who claimed the Christmas decorations were not religious symbols, while a chanukiyah or other Chanukah items would be. The holiday concert was to include songs about Santa, reindeer and trees, which the principal defended as being “cultural” symbols, not religious ones.

The principal’s position drew rebukes over the weekend from Janet Fraser, chairperson of the board of education. “The VBE sincerely regrets any practices at General Gordon Elementary that have negatively impacted a sense of inclusion and representation for students and parents within our school community,” she wrote. “As chairperson, I apologize on behalf of the board to the students and their families who did not feel welcomed and included at their school. We acknowledge that, in the interpretation and implementation of our policies, there has been confusion about what is permitted as part of upcoming winter celebrations, including Chanukah. The board chairperson and school district staff will be meeting with members of the families … to ensure that their children, as well as all others, are included and represented in their school.”

In response to Fraser’s statement, Rob Fleming, B.C. minister of education tweeted: “ALL children, regardless of ethnicity, religion or gender should feel and be welcome to celebrate who they are in every single one of our #bced schools.… Thank you for your leadership upholding inclusive schools @VSB39 and @janetrfraser.… Let’s #celebrate diversity this year!”

Administrators were to meet with school officials, parents and students Monday to address the issue.

“It is called a public school, so, if you’re going to invite everybody, you’ve sort of got to include everybody,” 11-year-old Maya Sontz told CTV news.